If you’ve ever questioned whether that extra 5% you offered was worth it, you’re not alone. As a Partner Success Manager working with hundreds of hotels, I get this question all the time: How do we know the cash back is actually working? Cash back is not just a perk. It is a strategic lever for driving more direct bookings, guest loyalty, and long-term margin growth. Here’s how to evaluate its impact:

‍

‍
Cash Back Cost vs. Saved Commission

‍
A 5% cash back reward typically costs your hotel far less than a 15%-20 OTA commission. If you are spending $10 to $20 to convert a direct booking instead of $40+ through an OTA, that is immediate ROI in pure margin retention. Importantly, with The Guestbook, you only pay for guests who actually enroll and engage, not 100% of guests coming through an OTA channel. This means you are incentivizing guests to act in a more loyal way, while ensuring your acquisition spend is tied directly to measurable loyalty and repeat behavior, not one-off transactions.

‍

‍
Monitor Direct Booking Uplift

‍
By clearly presenting a tangible, immediate benefit at the point of booking, you reduce the friction of choosing the direct channel. Guests recognize the value of earning and redeeming rewards, which not only converts them in the moment but also builds a strong incentive to continue booking direct in the future.
‍

‍

Track Repeat Behavior and Lifetime Value

‍
Cash back not only drives direct bookings, it proves repeat behavior and strengthens loyalty. Guests who understand they can earn and redeem rewards again are far more likely to return. Even a single repeat stay from what would have been a one-and-done guest can double lifetime value while steadily reducing acquisition costs over time.

‍

‍
Loyalty Funnel Engagement

‍
Loyalty Funnel Engagement measures how guests interact with The Guestbook beyond their initial booking. By tracking actions such as reward redemptions, referrals, and repeat bookings, hotels can see clear indicators of growing guest loyalty. Each step of engagement deepens the guest’s connection with the property.
When measured holistically, cash back isn’t just an expense, it’s an investment that pays for itself many times over. By lowering distribution costs, boosting direct conversions, and cultivating long-term guest loyalty, The Guestbook turns a simple 5% offer into a powerful engine for sustainable growth.